Trade Secret Misappropriation in Israel: Taking, Use and Disclosure

In an Israeli trade secret misappropriation claim, two distinct questions must be answered. First, does the information qualify as a trade secret under Section 5 of the Commercial Torts Law, 5759-1999? Second, what did the defendant actually do with it? Information may be confidential and commercially valuable without having been misappropriated.

The requirements for protected information are discussed separately in our guide to trade secrets in Israel. This article addresses the next stage: the conduct that constitutes misappropriation under Section 6 of the Commercial Torts Law, 5759-1999.

The statute distinguishes several situations. A secret may be taken through improper means. Information may be disclosed with consent but subsequently used for an unauthorized purpose. It may be transferred to another person. A third party receiving it may also incur liability where that party knew, or where the circumstances made it apparent, that the information originated in prohibited conduct. For foreign counsel considering an Israeli claim, these distinctions determine which facts and evidence will be required. A claim based on unauthorized acquisition is not necessarily proved in the same way as a claim based on breach of a contractual duty or a third party’s knowing receipt.

Taking a trade secret by improper means

Section 6(b)(1) addresses taking a trade secret without its owner’s consent by improper means, and the use of the secret by the person who took it.

Taking information is different from taking a physical object. When a file is copied, a document photographed or confidential information learned, the original information remains with its owner. What the owner loses is exclusive control over who knows it. It is therefore unnecessary to show that the defendant removed an original document or deleted information from the claimant’s computers. The defendant may have acquired the secret by obtaining information that can be understood or reproduced.

The manner of acquisition nevertheless matters. Unauthorized access to computer systems or confidential files is a clear example of improper means. In Gmida v. Fisher, Tel Aviv District Court, Civil Case 2117/07 (5 December 2012), the court found that the defendant used trade secrets received from a former employee of the claimant, after information had been unlawfully taken from the claimant’s computers. The recipient was not merely passive: she was involved in receiving information obtained through unauthorized computer access and encouraged its continued transmission.

In Korea Motors Israel Ltd. v. Ungar, Tel Aviv District Court, Civil Case 2262/08 (10 March 2021), the court also examined business information gathered through unauthorized computer access. Business plans, proposals, customer information, prices and other commercial data may form the subject of misappropriation when access to them is obtained improperly. The subsequent appellate proceedings are discussed separately in the Israeli case law concerning that dispute.

Section 6(b)(1) does not require the secret to be taken directly from its owner. The provision also applies where the information is taken from another person who knows the secret. Protection is not lost merely because the owner previously disclosed the information to an employee, consultant, supplier or another authorized recipient.

Information disclosed with consent but used for another purpose

A different situation arises where the owner voluntarily provides confidential information. A business may disclose pricing data to a distributor, a business plan to a prospective investor, a technical specification to a potential customer or engineering information during negotiations. Receiving the information in those circumstances is not, by itself, an unlawful taking.

Section 6(b)(2) addresses subsequent use. Use of a trade secret without the owner’s consent constitutes misappropriation where that use breaches a contractual or fiduciary obligation owed to the owner.

The purpose for which the information was supplied is therefore central. Permission to review material in connection with a possible investment is not necessarily permission to establish a competing business using that material. Providing specifications for a quotation is not necessarily authorization to manufacture a product based on them. Where a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) exists, the permitted uses must also be assessed in light of the terms and scope of the contractual undertaking.

In Electra v. Wawi, Central District Court, Civil Case 24242-03-18 (15 July 2018), the allegedly confidential information had not been taken from Electra without permission. It had been provided in the course of a distribution relationship. The issue was therefore whether the recipient made unauthorized use of it. At the interim relief stage, the court found insufficient evidence of actual use. Possession of confidential information by the other party was not, without more, proof that the information had been used.

What amounts to use of a trade secret?

Use is not confined to copying a document word for word or operating a process in precisely its original form. Section 9 of the Commercial Torts Law provides that use of altered information may still constitute use of a trade secret where there is substantial similarity between the protected secret and the information actually used.

The relevant question is whether the defendant exploited the protected information. Depending on the facts, this may include implementing a confidential technical process, setting prices using a competitor’s non-public data, approaching customers with confidential knowledge of their contractual terms, or materially shortening a development process using information obtained from the secret’s owner.

Where liability is alleged on the basis of a contract or fiduciary duty, the scope of that duty must also be considered. Using part of the information may breach the obligation even if the defendant combines it with other material or adapts it for a different application.

Access alone does not establish use. In Integrity Software 2011 Ltd. v. Gonen, Tel Aviv District Court, Civil Case 65217-06-15 (8 February 2018), a misappropriation claim failed after the claimant did not establish the required similarity between the technology of a new venture and the alleged protected information. The decision distinguishes exposure to know-how in the course of a joint venture from proof that the protected information was actually exploited.

Disclosing or transferring a secret to another person is also use

Section 5 expressly includes transfer to another person within the definition of “use.” The recipient of a trade secret therefore need not exploit it personally in order for an unauthorized disclosure to amount to prohibited use. Transferring the secret to a third party may itself be actionable where the other statutory requirements are met.

Transfer does not mean a legal assignment of rights. It may consist of sending a file, handing over a document, granting access to a database, communicating confidential data or otherwise allowing a third party to learn the protected information.

In S.P.G. Communication Center Ltd. v. Elta Systems Ltd., Central District Court, Civil Case 30839-02-11 (18 September 2016), the claimant alleged that technical information supplied during a procurement process was transferred to the competitor ultimately selected to perform the work. The claim was dismissed because the claimant did not establish that the information qualified as a trade secret or that it had been transferred to the competitor. A competing solution that appears similar is not a substitute for proving what the secret was, how it reached the competitor and how it was used.

Liability of a third party receiving misappropriated information

Section 6(b)(3) extends potential liability beyond the person who originally acquired the secret improperly or breached a duty of confidentiality. A person receiving or using a trade secret without its owner’s consent may also be liable where, at the time of receipt or use, the person knew, or it was apparent, that the information had been transferred through conduct prohibited under Section 6(b)(1) or 6(b)(2), including an earlier prohibited transfer.

This provision addresses situations in which a competitor receives confidential information through an employee, consultant or intermediary rather than obtaining it directly from its owner. The inquiry focuses on the recipient’s knowledge and on the circumstances in which the information was received.

In Gmida v. Fisher, the court found that the recipient was not a passive beneficiary. She had received information over time through intrusions into the claimant’s computer systems and had encouraged further transfers. Those circumstances supported liability for receiving and using misappropriated secrets.

Section 8 provides a specific protection in relation to Section 6(b)(3) for a person who purchased and received a trade secret in good faith and for consideration, unless the court concludes that justice between the parties requires liability to be imposed. This is not a defense for a recipient who knew, at the relevant time, that the information came from an improper source.

How can the claimant prove that the secret was used?

Use of confidential information often occurs outside the owner’s view. Section 10 addresses the evidentiary difficulty through a statutory presumption of use. The presumption arises where the secret was known to the defendant or the defendant had access to it, and the information actually used by the defendant is substantially similar to the information comprising the trade secret.

The presumption does not relieve the claimant of identifying and establishing the trade secret itself. Nor is access to the information sufficient on its own. Substantial similarity between the protected information and the defendant’s actual use must also be shown.

In Integrity Software 2011 Ltd. v. Gonen, the required similarity was not established, and prior exposure to information from the earlier venture did not suffice. Similarly, in S.P.G. Communication Center Ltd. v. Elta Systems Ltd., broad technological similarities did not prove that the competing solution had been developed using improperly transferred confidential information.

Use may also be established through circumstantial evidence. Access to the information, substantial similarity, an otherwise unexplained shortening of the development process, a sudden change in commercial conduct after receipt of the information, or a sequence of disclosures by someone with access to the secret may, in an appropriate factual context, support an inference of use. Each item must be considered together with the other evidence and with the nature of the information claimed to be secret.

Independent development and lawful reverse engineering are not misappropriation

Trade secret law does not give the holder a monopoly over the result itself. A person who reaches the same information through independent development does not thereby take another party’s secret.

Section 6(c) further provides that discovering a trade secret through reverse engineering does not, by itself, constitute an improper means of acquisition. In principle, a competitor may analyze a product or process lawfully obtained and attempt to understand the information embodied in it.

The words “by itself” matter. Reverse engineering does not excuse an earlier wrongful act. Where access to a product, system or information was obtained through intrusion, breach of confidence or another improper means, subsequent analysis does not erase the original manner of acquisition.

Information that can be lawfully and readily discovered may also fail to qualify as a trade secret under Section 5 in the first place. The possibility that a defendant could theoretically have developed the same information independently is different from evidence that the defendant actually did so. A hypothetical lawful route does not convert an improper taking into independent development.

Identify both the trade secret and the alleged act of misappropriation

A claim should not rest solely on broad allegations that the defendant “took our know-how,” “used our method” or “copied our idea.” The claimant must identify the particular information alleged to be secret, explain why it qualifies for protection, show how it reached the defendant and identify the conduct that is alleged to be unlawful.

In Mintzer v. Solsi-Shelef, Tel Aviv District Court, Civil Case 24970-11-09 (5 January 2014), a misappropriation allegation was dismissed where the claimant failed to identify the particular information allegedly taken or establish that it had been used. A general description of an idea for a real estate project was insufficient.

The same distinction was central in S.P.G. Communication Center Ltd. v. Elta Systems Ltd.. It was not enough to suggest that technological knowledge developed by the claimant somehow found its way into a competing product. The claimant had to establish what the confidential information was, how it was protected, whether and how it had been transferred, and the connection between that information and the competing solution.

For a business or foreign law firm considering trade secret litigation in Israel, the legal basis of the claim should be matched to the evidence from the outset. An allegation of improper acquisition, unauthorized use in breach of a duty, disclosure to a third party or knowing receipt of misappropriated information requires a different factual foundation. Similarity between competing businesses or products is not enough: the claimant must identify the secret, trace the relevant access or transfer and establish what the defendant did with it.

Have a question about the article?

You might also be interested in