Employee Trade Secrets in Israel: Confidentiality, Loyalty and Non-Compete Clauses

An employee’s move to a competing business does not, by itself, constitute trade secret misappropriation under Israeli law. Employees may leave their employer, continue practicing their profession and make use of the skills and general professional experience they have acquired. They may not, however, take the former employer’s protected confidential business information and exploit it for themselves or a competitor.

Many Israeli employment-related trade secret disputes turn on this distinction. The question is not merely whether the employee signed a confidentiality clause or a non-compete undertaking. It is what information is at issue, whether that information qualifies as a trade secret, how it was protected, how the employee obtained it and what the employee did with it afterwards. For foreign businesses employing staff in Israel, and foreign counsel considering claims arising from an employee’s departure, these questions should be examined separately.

Not everything an employee learns belongs to the employer

Section 5 of Israel’s Commercial Torts Law, 5759-1999, protects business information that is not publicly known or readily discoverable by lawful means, whose secrecy confers a competitive advantage and whose owner has taken reasonable measures to preserve its confidentiality. These requirements apply even when the information is known to an employee. Information does not automatically become a trade secret merely because it was created within the company or learned in the course of employment.

An important distinction is between the employer’s particular confidential information and knowledge that has become part of an employee’s professional abilities. Section 7(a)(1) expressly excludes liability for misappropriation where knowledge embodied in a trade secret was acquired during employment with its owner and became part of the employee’s general professional skills.

An engineer does not have to forget how to develop a product, a salesperson does not lose the ability to negotiate, and a manager need not disregard experience gained in managing people or processes. Practical knowledge acquired through successes and failures may also form part of a person’s professional experience.

The position is different where the information is specific to the business: source code, formulas, unpublished specifications, development plans, internal pricing, forecasts, profit margins, databases, customer contract terms or technical information that the company keeps confidential. Familiarity with such information, even the ability to recall it from memory, does not necessarily turn it into a general professional skill. The content of the information matters more than whether it is stored in a file, an email or the employee’s memory.

For the statutory requirements, see What Qualifies as a Trade Secret in Israel?

Using an employer’s information can be misappropriation even if the employee received it lawfully

Employees are ordinarily given access to their employer’s information with permission. In many disputes, the question is therefore not how the employee initially obtained the information, but what happened to it later.

Section 6(b)(2) of the Commercial Torts Law provides that unauthorized use of a trade secret constitutes misappropriation when it breaches a contractual or fiduciary obligation owed by the user to the secret’s owner. The employee need not steal a physical document. Information legitimately received for the performance of a job may become the subject of a claim if it is subsequently exploited for an unauthorized purpose.

For example, an employee with access to confidential pricing, customer or development information may later use that information to establish a competing business or disclose it to a new employer. The different statutory forms of acquisition, use and transfer are examined in Trade Secret Misappropriation in Israel: Taking, Use and Disclosure.

An employee’s duties of loyalty extend beyond trade secrets

An employment relationship also entails obligations of good faith, loyalty and fidelity. While employment continues, those obligations may prohibit certain conduct even when the employer cannot establish that particular information satisfies every statutory requirement for a trade secret.

In Diesenhaus Unitours Incoming Tourism v. Tuhfa Ali, Jerusalem Regional Labour Court, Case 2977/09 (8 June 2013), the agency list in dispute was not established to be a trade secret. Nevertheless, the court found breaches of duties of loyalty and good faith, in circumstances that included steps to establish a competing business and divert commercial relationships during the relevant period.

The distinction is material. Failure to prove that information is a trade secret does not authorize an employee to act in a conflict of interest while employed, redirect business opportunities to themselves or use their position to build a competing operation. After employment ends, however, duties of loyalty should not be assumed to create a general and unlimited prohibition on competition. Any attempt to restrict an individual’s work in their profession requires identification of a concrete legitimate interest justifying the restriction.

A confidentiality clause does not make all employer information a trade secret

Employment agreements often define “confidential information” very broadly. Some purport to treat everything an employee encounters at work as belonging to the employer and prohibit its use after the relationship ends.

Such undertakings may have independent contractual significance, but they do not replace the statutory requirements of the Commercial Torts Law. Information that is public or readily obtainable does not become a statutory trade secret merely because an employment agreement labels it “confidential.”

A carefully drafted confidentiality undertaking is nevertheless important. It can clarify what information was supplied to the employee, why access was permitted, which uses remain prohibited after employment ends and which materials must be returned or deleted. See also Non-Disclosure Agreements in Israel: When to Use an NDA.

Joining a competitor is not prohibited in itself

The fact that an employee moves directly to a competing company is not sufficient grounds, without more, to prevent the new employment. Israeli employment law balances the former employer’s legitimate interests against the employee’s freedom of occupation and the public interest in employee mobility and competition.

In Frumer and Check Point Software Technologies Ltd. v. Redguard Ltd., National Labour Court, Labour Appeal 164/99, PDA 34, 294 (1999), the court distinguished general skills and experience that an employee may take to a new position from trade secrets belonging to the former employer. Moving to a competitor did not, in itself, justify prohibiting the employment.

This approach is consistent with the Supreme Court’s decision in AES System Inc. v. Saar, Civil Appeal 6601/96, PD 54(3) 850 (2000). A bare undertaking not to compete, without a legitimate interest to protect, does not justify restricting freedom of occupation. A non-compete clause in an Israeli employment agreement is therefore not enforceable merely because the employee signed it.

When can an employee’s future work be restricted?

Israeli case law recognizes several interests that may support an appropriately tailored restriction, including protecting trade secrets, special investment in employee training, special consideration paid for the undertaking not to compete and circumstances involving duties of good faith and loyalty. The existence of such an interest and the proportionality of any restriction must be examined in the particular circumstances.

In Avishai v. Wissotzky Tea, Nazareth Regional Labour Court, Case 28192-12-10 (2 February 2011), the court rejected an employer’s attempt to prevent an employee from joining Unilever. The employer had not established a legitimate interest justifying the restriction and, in particular, had not shown that the employee was expected to use a trade secret in the proposed new role.

Even when an employee possesses apparently confidential information, it does not follow automatically that work for a competitor must be prohibited. The risk of actual use in the new position and the likely harm to the former employer must also be evaluated. Relief should protect the legitimate interest, not eliminate competition. If misuse of identified information can be restrained without preventing employment in the profession, a blanket prohibition on working for a competitor may go further than necessary.

Customer lists do not make customers the employer’s property

Disputes involving departing employees often concern customer relationships. Here too, professional contacts must be distinguished from confidential information.

An employee may know the major participants in an industry and retain professional relationships developed over a career. By contrast, a database containing prices, credit terms, renewal dates, purchasing histories, internal customer contacts, preferences and negotiation details may constitute confidential business information belonging to the employer.

In Sorovitz Marketing Ltd. v. Handiker Ltd., Rishon LeZion Magistrates’ Court, Civil Case 3810/07 (18 January 2010), the customer list included contractual terms, prices and profit information and was maintained in the employer’s systems. Its use to approach customers on behalf of a competitor was held to constitute trade secret misappropriation.

For the distinctions governing customer and supplier data, see Customer Lists as Trade Secrets in Israel: When Are They Protected?

Copying company files is different from relying on professional experience

The manner in which information leaves the business is often central to a post-employment dispute. Copying folders, forwarding documents to a personal email address, downloading a CRM database, transferring source code to a private repository or storing company documents in a personal cloud account may provide a very different factual foundation from the mere continued use of professional experience.

Nevertheless, the absence of physical copying does not conclusively resolve the issue. Specific protected information does not cease to be confidential simply because an employee remembers it. The question remains whether the knowledge has become part of general professional skills or is particular confidential business information that the employer is entitled to protect.

Accordingly, “I did not take any documents” is not necessarily a complete answer to an allegation of misuse. Equally, showing that an employee was familiar with information does not, without further evidence, establish misappropriation.

The new employer must also avoid using the former employer’s secrets

The legal risk is not confined to the departing employee. Section 6(b)(3) extends potential liability to a person who receives or uses a trade secret where that person knew, or it was apparent at the relevant time, that the information had been transferred through prohibited conduct.

A new employer receiving files, customer lists, source code, internal presentations or pricing materials from a recruit’s former employer should not treat those materials as professional experience brought by the recruit. Using the information may expose the new employer to liability as well.

In practical terms, onboarding an employee from a competitor should not involve receiving the previous employer’s materials. The employee should be instructed not to bring or use confidential information that they are not entitled to disclose. This protects the new business as well as respecting the former employer’s rights.

Protection starts before the employee resigns

An employer seeking to protect information from misuse by employees must take precautions while the employment relationship is ongoing. If every employee can access every database, if forwarding company files to personal accounts is routine and if no distinction is made between sensitive and ordinary information, it becomes harder to establish that reasonable steps were taken to maintain secrecy.

Effective protection generally involves role-based access, identification of sensitive material, confidentiality undertakings that describe the relevant categories of information, appropriate controls on copying and export, and an orderly offboarding process. Where a disclosure is suspected, prompt preservation of access logs, communications and other system records may be important before evidence is deleted or changed.

For departing employees, the corresponding distinction is between professional resources they may legitimately retain and information assets belonging to the employer. General knowledge, experience and skills remain available to the employee. Company databases, files and trade secrets do not become freely usable simply because the employee encountered them in performing their duties.

Relevant Israeli authorities also include AES System Inc. v. Saar and Elite v. Saranga. These principles are central when assessing an Israeli claim for misuse of confidential information or seeking appropriate relief in trade secret disputes in Israel.

Have a question about the article?

You might also be interested in