Hi-Sec v. ELTA: Broad Claim Construction Defeated Novelty, and Narrow Construction Could Not Save the Patent

In the petition to revoke Israeli Patent No. 235508, Hi-Sec Systems v. ELTA Systems Ltd. (August 25, 2026), Intellectual Property Adjudicator Dr. Roya Israeli ordered the revocation of ELTA’s patent concerning enhanced security for communication devices through an external modem. The Adjudicator held that, under a broad construction of the claims, the claimed invention encompassed solutions previously disclosed in the prior art and therefore lacked novelty. ELTA’s proposed narrower construction, requiring irreversible hardware neutralization of communication channels, was neither supported by the patent specification nor sufficiently disclosed to enable implementation. The invention also lacked an inventive step even under that narrower construction.

Background to the Dispute and the Patented Invention

Israeli Patent No. 235508, entitled “Modem for Retrofitting Wireless Devices and Methods of Use Thereof,” was filed in Israel on November 5, 2014, and registered on March 1, 2019.

The invention was intended to enable secure use of existing commercial communication devices, such as smartphones, in environments requiring a high level of information security. The proposed solution involved connecting an external device containing an auxiliary cellular modem to an existing device, for example through a USB port, while neutralizing at least one of the device’s original wireless communication channels.

In practical terms, the objective was to make an ordinary commercial smartphone suitable for defense-related use by routing communications through a secure external channel. The security concern was that sensitive information might otherwise be transmitted through communication channels that remained active in the original device.

The patent contained 49 claims, including three independent claims: claim 1 directed to a system, claim 11 to a method, and claim 21 to a computer program product.

In September 2019, ELTA filed a patent infringement action against Hi-Sec in the Haifa District Court (Civil Case No. 52297-09-19). Hi-Sec petitioned to revoke the patent. In April 2020, the court permitted the Registrar of Patents to hear the revocation proceedings and ELTA’s application to amend the patent. The infringement action was stayed pending the Registrar’s decision.

During the proceedings, ELTA sought to amend the patent claims. A first amendment application was partially allowed in 2021, but a further amendment application was rejected in August 2023. In that decision, the requested amendment was held to lack support in the patent specification, and the delay in filing the application was found to amount to bad faith.

The Dispute Over “Neutralized” and “Disabled”

The central dispute concerned two terms used in the patent claims: “Neutralized” and “Disabled.”

ELTA argued that both terms referred to irreversible hardware neutralization of the device’s original communication channels. In its view, software-based disabling did not provide the security required for defense applications because the disabled channels could be reactivated. Hardware neutralization, by contrast, would prevent reactivation even if the device fell into hostile hands.

The patent documents, however, pointed in a different direction.

Claim 1 used the term “Neutralized,” while independent claims 11 and 21 used “Disabled.” The dependent claims returned to “Neutralized,” some expressly specifying that neutralization could be accomplished by hardware, an operating system, software, or a combination of these means.

The distinction was not merely semantic. Disabling a channel through software is reversible, whereas irreversible hardware neutralization requires physical intervention in the device’s components. These are different technical approaches, with different consequences for the device’s operation and security.

The difficulty was particularly apparent in the method and computer program product claims. Claim 11, for example, described a device in which a wireless communication channel was “Disabled.” Claim 14, which indirectly depended on claim 11, allowed neutralization through hardware, software, or other means. This created an inconsistency between the narrow meaning ELTA attributed to disabling in the independent claim and the range of neutralization methods permitted by the dependent claims.

An examination of earlier versions of the patent application revealed a telling detail. The original wording of claim 1 included the expression “neutralized (/disabled ???),” with three question marks following the alternative term. This reinforced the Adjudicator’s conclusion that no clear distinction between the two terms had been established even during the drafting of the application.

Dr. Israeli held that the inconsistent terminology prevented a person skilled in the art from clearly identifying the boundaries of the claimed protection. The claims therefore failed to satisfy the clarity requirement under Regulation 20(a)(3) of the Israeli Patent Regulations.

Did Figure 5 Disclose Hardware Neutralization?

To support its narrower construction, ELTA relied on Figure 5 of the patent, a diagram showing a communication device connected to an external unit. Two X marks appeared on the interfaces between the device’s processor and its wireless communication components.

ELTA’s expert, Yaakov Klein, argued that those X marks would indicate irreversible hardware disconnection to a person skilled in the art. According to his testimony, this was a conventional notation in hardware diagrams for the physical disconnection of a component or conductor.

The Adjudicator rejected that argument. The patent specification did not explain the meaning of the X marks, and the text accompanying the figure used the term “Disabled,” which, in the context of the prior art, ordinarily referred to reversible disabling. Hi-Sec also presented earlier publications in which an X mark was used to depict reversible disconnection or disabling.

The explanation on page 7 of the patent specification likewise failed to support ELTA’s position. It stated that communication channels could be neutralized by any suitable method, including hardware, an operating system, or a kernel. The specification also referred to earlier solutions involving software-based disabling.

There was therefore no basis for construing “Neutralized” and “Disabled” as necessarily requiring irreversible hardware neutralization. Had ELTA intended these terms to carry that special technical meaning, it needed to define the meaning expressly in the patent documents.

Because ELTA’s proposed interpretation was inconsistent with the description of the invention, the Adjudicator found that the claims, on that interpretation, were not reasonably supported by the specification, contrary to Section 13(a) of the Israeli Patents Law.

The Patent Did Not Explain How to Achieve Irreversible Hardware Neutralization

The Adjudicator also considered the consequences of accepting ELTA’s contention that the invention required physical, irreversible neutralization of the communication channels. That construction raised a separate problem: the patent did not explain how such neutralization was to be performed.

Section 12(a) of the Israeli Patents Law requires a patent applicant to describe how to carry out the invention in sufficient detail to enable a person skilled in the art to perform it.

Irreversible hardware neutralization of communication components in a smartphone might require cutting conductors, drilling into a printed circuit board, or removing electronic components. Such operations demand precise knowledge of the device’s hardware architecture because an incorrect intervention may disable the device or impair its reliability.

In his expert opinion, Klein identified several possible techniques, including removing components with a soldering iron. During cross-examination, however, he modified his position and expressed reservations about component removal, explaining that it could cause software malfunctions and compromise device reliability. He then argued that the patent taught the disconnection of a particular conductor rather than the removal of components.

Dr. Israeli considered this change in testimony to undermine the expert’s credibility and to reinforce the conclusion that the patent did not provide clear implementation instructions.

The technical complexity was also reflected in the testimony of one of the inventors, Oded Nahmani. He explained that identifying the appropriate location for hardware intervention required substantial effort. The goal, he noted, was to obtain a functioning device after neutralization, not to destroy it.

These testimonies highlighted the deficiency in the patent disclosure. ELTA described a procedure that, on its own account, required considerable technical expertise, adaptation to different devices, and management of significant risks to their operation, yet the patent did not explain how to carry it out.

The Adjudicator found that a skilled person attempting to implement the invention under ELTA’s proposed construction would have to engage in extensive experimentation and guesswork. The patent did not give sufficient guidance for neutralizing the channels while preserving the device’s functionality.

The patent therefore failed to meet the sufficiency of disclosure requirement under Section 12(a) of the Patents Law.

Earlier “Smart Case” Publications Destroyed Novelty

On the question of novelty, Hi-Sec relied on two earlier US patent publications, US 2014/0221057 and US 2013/0324189, belonging to the same patent family.

Those publications described devices known as “Smart Cases,” which physically attach to existing commercial communication devices and add communication capabilities. Among other applications, they described channels suitable for military, law-enforcement, and tactical purposes.

The cases included an additional modem and a mechanism allowing users to switch between the device’s original communication channels and the external channels. Switching could be achieved by a physical switch or by a software switch displayed on the device’s screen.

ELTA argued that switching to an external communication channel was not equivalent to irreversible hardware neutralization. It also maintained that the earlier publications did not necessarily require all of the device’s original communication channels to be disabled.

ELTA’s patent claims, however, did not require all channels to be disabled; they required disabling at least one. Moreover, the software switching mechanism disclosed in the earlier publications allowed reversible disabling of the original communication channels and the routing of communications through an external channel.

Dr. Israeli concluded that this solution fell within the scope of the claims as drafted. The earlier publications disclosed the elements of the claimed system: an existing commercial communication device, an external device physically connected to it, an additional modem, and a mechanism for disabling original communications and using an alternative channel.

The Adjudicator held that each of the two earlier publications independently deprived the patent claims, including the dependent claims, of novelty.

ELTA’s principal distinction over the prior art thus failed. It sought to differentiate the patented invention by requiring irreversible hardware neutralization, but that limitation was not part of the supported definition of the invention.

Hardware Neutralization Also Lacked an Inventive Step

For the inventive-step analysis, the Adjudicator also examined the patent under ELTA’s narrower construction, assuming for that purpose that irreversible hardware neutralization was supported by the specification and could be implemented.

The analysis considered Security Technical Implementation Guides (STIGs) issued before the patent’s relevant date. Originating in the US defense establishment, these guidelines addressed the hardening of computer systems intended for environments with stringent security requirements.

Among other things, the guidelines required the physical removal of wireless communication cards from computers where removal was possible, rather than relying solely on software disabling. Where the cards could not be removed, the guidelines directed that the computers not be used in the relevant environment.

ELTA argued that the guidelines did not concern smartphones and that removing a communication card from a computer was materially different from disconnecting components mounted directly on a smartphone’s printed circuit board.

However, the testimony of Ehud Kauf, an expert for Hi-Sec, established that before the patent’s relevant date it was already customary to physically remove communication components from commercial devices to adapt them for defense use. As devices became smaller and components were mounted directly onto printed circuit boards, the practice was adapted to the removal of those components, a process referred to as “sterilization.”

The Adjudicator held that a skilled person seeking to adapt a commercial communication device for defense use would have had a clear motivation to combine the Smart Case solution with the guidance on physically removing communication components. Although hardware neutralization of smartphones was more complex than removing cards from computers, adapting the procedure to the device’s construction did not involve an inventive step.

A central point in the decision was the inconsistency in ELTA’s position concerning the knowledge of the skilled person. On one hand, ELTA argued that the X marks in Figure 5 enabled such a person to understand how to perform irreversible hardware neutralization without detailed instructions. On the other, it maintained that the same person would not have deduced from the STIG guidance and the prior art how to perform a similar operation on a smartphone.

Dr. Israeli rejected the combination of those positions. If irreversible hardware neutralization was a routine operation that a skilled person could perform without instructions, it did not involve an inventive step. If it was a complex, non-obvious operation, the patent failed to provide the instructions needed to carry it out.

The Adjudicator expressed the outcome succinctly: “Whichever path is taken, the patent must be revoked” (translated from Hebrew).

The Allegation of Breach of the Duty of Disclosure Was Rejected

Hi-Sec also argued that ELTA had breached its disclosure obligations under Section 18 of the Patents Law by failing to submit material prior-art publications to the examiner.

This allegation was rejected. Dr. Israeli found no proof that ELTA had deliberately withheld material documents in bad faith. The evidence indicated that the invention had apparently been developed in an attempt to anticipate the security needs of a military customer, rather than on the basis of the publications Hi-Sec later introduced in the revocation proceedings. Nor was it established that ELTA had been aware of many of those publications at the relevant time.

The Adjudicator distinguished between an invention’s substantive failure to qualify for patent protection and an intentional breach of the duty of disclosure. Although the prior publications established substantive grounds for revocation, they did not establish that ELTA had deliberately concealed them during examination of the application.

The Claim-Construction Dilemma

The decision in Hi-Sec v. ELTA illustrates the importance of defining the distinguishing technical feature of an invention when drafting the patent application.

ELTA sought protection for a method of securing communication devices through irreversible hardware neutralization, but employed broader terms in its claims that also encompassed software-based disabling. When the broader solution was shown to have been disclosed in earlier publications, ELTA attempted to rely on a narrower meaning of those terms. The patent, however, neither defined that meaning nor explained how to implement it.

Nor did it assist ELTA to argue that hardware neutralization was within the skilled person’s existing knowledge. The prior art, particularly the STIG guidance combined with the Smart Case publications, supported the conclusion that using such neutralization did not involve an inventive step.

From a patent-drafting perspective, the problem is not the use of broad terms such as “Neutralized” as such. Broad claiming may be justified where the invention supports several ways of implementation. The difficulty arises when the patent owner seeks to establish patentability on the basis of one particular implementation, although the claims also cover other approaches already known in the art and the specification does not teach how to perform the implementation said to distinguish the invention.

Here, the attempt to narrow the claims during the revocation proceedings could not bridge the gap between the invention ELTA maintained it had developed and the invention actually defined in its patent documents. That gap led to the patent’s revocation.

Have a question about the article?

You might also be interested in