Trademark Cancellation and Revocation in Israel: Invalid Registration, Bad Faith and Non-Use

Registration of a trademark in Israel gives its proprietor important exclusive rights, but it does not make the registration immune from challenge. An earlier rights holder may seek deletion of a mark that should never have been registered; a competitor may seek cancellation for non-use; and a party affected by an incorrect entry may apply to rectify the register.

The Israeli Trademarks Ordinance [New Version], 5732-1972, provides separate mechanisms under Sections 38, 39 and 41. The grounds, standing, deadlines, evidence and possible outcome depend on the route selected. These procedures concern registered trademarks and should be distinguished from opposition to a mark that has been accepted but not yet registered, or cancellation of a registered authorization to use the mark under Section 52.

Three Routes for Challenging an Israeli Trademark Registration

Rectification under Section 38: an affected party may seek correction of a register entry that was made without sufficient cause, remains there unlawfully, was wrongly omitted or contains a defect or error. The requested remedy can concern the registration as a whole or a particular entry or limitation.

Deletion under Section 39: the registration can be challenged on specified eligibility grounds, unfair competition affecting the claimant’s rights in Israel or filing in bad faith. The applicable time limits differ depending on the basis relied upon.

Cancellation for non-use under Section 41: an interested party may seek cancellation for all or part of the registered goods or services where the statutory requirements relating to lack of bona fide intention or use are satisfied.

These are not alternative labels for the same cause of action. The initiating application should identify the precise provision, factual basis and relief sought. See the Israel Patent Office’s official register-rectification and cancellation service.

Rectification of the Trademarks Register Under Section 38

Section 38 addresses entries that were made without sufficient cause, wrongly remain on the register, were omitted or contain an error or defect. A party injured by such a matter may seek correction through the Registrar’s statutory powers.

The precise request matters. Where the problem affects only particular goods or services or a recorded detail, a focused amendment may be appropriate rather than complete removal of the mark.

Rectification by a third party alleging defective entitlement must be distinguished from an ordinary administrative change requested by the proprietor under Section 36. A contractual or commercial disagreement does not itself establish a defect in the register unless an applicable legal ground is shown.

Deleting a Registration That Should Not Have Been Granted

Section 39(a) covers grounds including ineligibility for registration under Sections 7–11 of the Ordinance, and registration creating unfair competition in relation to the applicant’s rights in Israel. Potential grounds may include a lack of distinctive character, a descriptive or misleading mark, a conflict with relevant prior rights or another statutory bar.

Under Section 39(a), an application based on the grounds specified there must generally be filed within five years from the issue of the registration certificate. Special rules apply in certain circumstances, including arrangements concerning foreign registrations under Section 16. The five-year period must not be applied indiscriminately to every proceeding involving a registered trademark.

An applicant should identify which feature made registration improper: the mark itself, the prior mark or other right, the classes or goods concerned, or the circumstances of registration. Mere commercial objection to a competitor’s trademark is insufficient.

In the Israeli proceedings involving Tzvaot Hashem v. Chabad Youth Organization, the appellate court upheld deletion of a trademark on public-policy grounds while overturning the Registrar’s separate conclusion of bad faith. The distinction illustrates that ineligibility and bad faith should not be inferred automatically from one another.

Bad-Faith Trademark Registration Can Be Challenged at Any Time

Section 39(a1) creates a material exception to the ordinary time limit: an application for deletion on the ground that the original registration application was filed in bad faith may be submitted at any time.

Bad faith requires an evidentiary basis addressing the circumstances of filing, the applicant’s knowledge, previous business relationships and conduct relating to the mark. Filing for a mark similar to an existing mark is not automatically bad faith, nor does every registration lacking distinctiveness necessarily establish dishonest conduct.

For example, a former distributor who seeks to register the overseas brand owner’s mark in Israel may raise a different factual question from an independent business that adopted a similar term without any prior connection. Contracts, correspondence, historical use and filing records may be decisive.

For foreign companies, the lack of the five-year bar can be important in an old registration dispute, but it does not remove the need to prove the bad-faith ground itself.

Cancellation for Non-Use Under Section 41

Section 41 permits an interested person to seek cancellation of all or part of a registration on specified non-use grounds. The statutory provisions distinguish lack of bona fide intention to use accompanied by absence of bona fide use from non-use during the three years immediately preceding the cancellation application.

The inquiry concerns the relevant registered mark and the goods or services at issue. It is not enough to show generally that the proprietor operates a business somewhere, nor does use for one product necessarily preserve the entire specification.

It is important to avoid a common misunderstanding: the three-year non-use provision refers to the period preceding the application for cancellation, rather than a universal automatic cancellation three years after registration.

What Counts as Bona Fide Use of a Trademark in Israel?

The assessment is fact-specific. Genuine marketing and sale of goods or the relevant provision of services in Israel may support use, but the evidence must connect the activity to the registered mark and the goods or services covered by the registration.

The Ordinance includes particular rules concerning mere advertising, use by registered authorized users and forms of the mark differing only in particulars that do not alter its distinctive character. An updated logo, licensing arrangement or marketing campaign therefore requires factual and statutory analysis rather than a presumption that it necessarily preserves or fails to preserve registration.

Where a foreign proprietor relies on imported products or sales through a local distributor, documentary evidence should identify the goods, dates, mark as used, distributor and relevant Israeli transactions. Global turnover and worldwide reputation do not automatically establish bona fide use in Israel for the particular registered goods.

Can Special Circumstances Excuse Non-Use?

Section 41 recognizes an exception where non-use results from special circumstances in the trade rather than an intention not to use or to abandon the mark in relation to the relevant goods.

Whether a claimed obstacle satisfies this exception depends on the evidence and circumstances. A general assertion that commercial plans were delayed or the market was difficult is not sufficient without connecting the circumstances to the actual period and goods in question.

A registrant should therefore preserve records of the asserted external circumstances, the efforts undertaken to market the goods and the factual reasons that use did not occur.

How Can an Applicant Prove Non-Use?

Proving a negative can be more difficult than producing one invoice showing a sale. A reliable inquiry may include market checks with retailers and distributors, product catalogues, import information, internet archives, advertising records and documented efforts to locate goods in Israel.

The evidence should cover the specific registered goods or services and the relevant three-year period. A general internet search with no results may be relevant but does not necessarily establish non-use. Private investigation can be useful in some cases, but is not itself a separate statutory prerequisite.

Foreign brand owners defending a cancellation proceeding should organize evidence by the particular goods in the registration and the dates of actual activity. Non-specific promotional materials may not establish use for every item claimed.

Full Cancellation Versus Partial Cancellation

Under Section 41, a cancellation request may concern all or some of the goods or services covered by a registration. An applicant challenging a broad registration should identify the portion allegedly unused, while the owner should demonstrate the goods or services actually supported by bona fide use.

A trademark with activity in one part of a class does not necessarily remain protected for every item in its original specification simply because there has been some use. Conversely, an allegation of non-use for a few products should not automatically result in deletion of genuinely supported rights for other goods.

Targeted relief can be commercially significant in negotiations over a competing mark, coexistence agreements or entry into the Israeli market.

Who May File a Cancellation or Deletion Application?

Standing depends on the statutory route. Section 38 refers to a person affected or injured by the relevant register entry. Section 41 refers to an interested person seeking cancellation for non-use. Section 39 has its own statutory grounds and framework.

The applicant should identify the registration numbers, the relevant goods or services and the exact correction or cancellation requested. The legal basis should be matched with the facts and supporting documents rather than combining mutually inconsistent grounds without explanation.

The official Israel Patent Office service describes online filing, official fees by the classes concerned and how the Registrar handles the proceeding after submission.

Procedure Before the Registrar of Trademarks

The process begins with a reasoned application specifying the statutory grounds, facts and requested remedy, together with the applicable fee. The registered proprietor receives a copy and an opportunity to respond under the governing Regulations.

The evidentiary stage may include affidavits, invoices, commercial records, investigation reports, advertising and samples of actual trademark use. Depending on the case, witnesses may be examined and an oral hearing may be held before the Registrar.

A failure by the proprietor to respond does not dispense with the applicant’s duty to provide sufficient evidence for the requested remedy. The Registrar may grant or dismiss the application, limit the registration or order an appropriate correction in accordance with the grounds established.

For foreign counsel, the proceeding should be viewed as contentious administrative litigation, not as an informal register update.

What Is the Difference Between Cancellation and Opposition?

Opposition under Section 24 takes place after the Registrar has accepted and published a trademark application but before registration. A post-registration challenge under Sections 38, 39 or 41 concerns a right already entered on the register.

The distinction affects when the claim can be filed, which grounds are available and what evidence and deadlines govern the proceeding. A foreign brand owner aware of an earlier pending application should consider whether to oppose during the three-month window rather than assume it can later rely on the identical process.

See Trademark Opposition in Israel: Grounds, Procedure and Evidence. In Salt Company of Israel v. Super Medic, the Israeli Registrar addressed questions arising from a later deletion request following a failure to oppose earlier, illustrating why procedural timing deserves attention.

Does Filing a Cancellation Request Stop a Trademark Infringement Lawsuit?

Not automatically. A defendant to trademark infringement proceedings may challenge validity or the claimed scope of the proprietor’s rights and consider a separate cancellation or rectification proceeding before the Registrar. Filing such a request does not by itself erase the mark or automatically stay the civil action.

The relationship between the proceedings requires case-specific analysis of the allegations, stage of litigation, legal grounds and anticipated effect of the Registrar’s decision. A court infringement claim focuses on the defendant’s use and the rights being enforced, whereas a Registrar proceeding challenges the registration.

The distinction is explained in Trademark Infringement Litigation in Israel and the broader Trademark Litigation in Israel practice page.

Is Cancellation of a Registered Trademark Licence the Same Procedure?

No. Section 52 addresses variation or cancellation of a registered authorization to use a trademark, rather than deletion of the underlying mark. A brand owner may remain proprietor of the mark even after authorization given to a former distributor is cancelled.

Conversely, deletion of the trademark itself may affect authorizations dependent on it. The relevant rules and hearing requirements are examined in Cancellation of a Registered Trademark Licence in Israel.

Appeals and Practical Steps for Foreign Counsel

Decisions of the Israeli Registrar under the relevant rectification and non-use provisions may be appealed to the District Court according to the Ordinance and applicable procedural rules. The governing appeal deadline and notification requirements should be confirmed for the particular decision; an appeal is not an unrestricted opportunity to present a new factual case.

Before bringing or resisting a challenge, obtain current register extracts, the full filing and registration history, any material agreements and evidence directed to the statutory ground. In a non-use matter, the relevant period and precise goods or services are essential. In a bad-faith matter, records of previous relations and the applicant’s conduct at filing may be central.

The governing provisions are Sections 38, 39 and 41 of the Trademarks Ordinance, the Trademarks Regulations, 1940, and the Registrar’s relevant procedural directions. Drori Stav IP advises and represents foreign trademark attorneys and international businesses in Israeli cancellation, opposition and enforcement proceedings.

Have a question about the article?

You might also be interested in